The prop trading industry has grown rapidly in recent years, with traders around the world looking for firms that can provide funding, fair evaluation models, and reliable payouts. Among the many names on the market, The Trading Pit and Blue Guardian have gained strong visibility.
The Trading Pit is often praised for its European regulatory foundation, partnerships with regulated brokers, and broad asset coverage. Blue Guardian, on the other hand, is well-known for high profit splits (up to 90%), flexible challenges, and a strong community driven by active Discord groups and football sponsorship. But which one is the better choice for you? Let’s go step by step and compare them in detail across multiple categories.
The Trading Pit vs Blue Guardian:Quick Overview
At a glance, both prop firms launched in 2021, but their positioning is quite different. The Trading Pit was born in Liechtenstein under a European holding company, aiming to bring transparency and compliance to a market often accused of being opaque. Blue Guardian started from the UK/UAE, with a marketing approach that emphasizes trader-friendly profit splits, quick payouts, and community engagement.
- Founded: 2021 • Liechtenstein (EU)
- Assets: Forex, CFDs, Commodities, Indices, Crypto, Futures & Stocks
- Platforms: MT4, MT5, cTrader, DXtrade, NinjaTrader
- Profit split: 50%–80% depending on program
- Edge: Transparency, regulated brokers, long-term trader trust
- Founded: 2021 • UAE/UK
- Programs: 1-Step • 2-Step • 3-Step • Instant Funding
- Profit split: Up to 90%
- Brand: Sponsorship of Birmingham City F.C., active Discord
- Edge: High payout, fast withdrawals, fee refunds
Profit Split & Payout
Profit split refers to the percentage of profits traders keep after passing an evaluation and trading a funded account. Beyond the percentage, payout speed and consistency are equally important. Here’s how The Trading Pit and Blue Guardian differ:
- Profit split: 50–80% (depending on account size and program).
- Payout: Scheduled every 14 days, requires minimum profitable days.
- Strength: Transparent, EU-compliant, handled via regulated broker partners.
- Best for: Traders who prioritize stability and legal safety over maximum profit splits.
- Profit split: Up to 90% (most traders report ~85% in practice).
- Payout: Fast, often within 1 week; crypto withdrawals (BTC, ETH, USDT, etc.) nearly instant.
- Strength: Fee refunds after payout milestones, making long-term trading less costly.
- Best for: Traders seeking higher profits, quick withdrawals, and strong community support.
Reliability & Brand Trust
Reliability and brand trust matter as much as profit potential. A firm’s legal foundation, regulatory alignment, and community strength all shape a trader’s confidence. Here’s how The Trading Pit and Blue Guardian compare:
- Headquarters: Liechtenstein (EU).
- Regulation: Operates under a European legal framework, ensuring compliance and safety.
- Broker partnerships: Works with regulated brokers like FXFlat and WH SelfInvest for transparent execution.
- Brand reach: Credible but less visible in the global retail prop market.
- Best for: Traders who value legal protection, regulatory trust, and stability.
- Founded: UK (2021), with operations expanding into UAE.
- Community: Large and active Discord group providing peer support and guidance.
- Brand visibility: Sponsorship of Birmingham City F.C. boosts recognition outside trading circles.
- Regulation: Not EU-regulated, relies on internal policies.
- Limitations: Restricted in many countries (e.g., Vietnam, Malaysia, China, plus others in Asia and Africa).
- Best for: Traders who want community engagement and strong brand visibility.
Pros & Cons
Every prop firm has strengths and weaknesses. The key is understanding which strengths align with your goals, and which weaknesses you can tolerate. Below is a balanced overview of both sides.
- ✅ Multi-asset access: CFDs, Futures, Stocks
- ✅ EU compliance & regulated broker partnerships
- ✅ Platform diversity: MT4, MT5, cTrader, DXtrade, NinjaTrader
- ❌ Profit split max ~80%, lower than competitors
- ❌ Less brand recognition globally
- ✅ High profit split (up to 90%) + fee refunds
- ✅ Guardian Protector tool for daily loss limits
- ✅ Large Discord community + football sponsorship
- ❌ Restricted countries (Vietnam, Malaysia, China, etc.)
- ❌ Limited product scope: mainly Forex & CFDs
- ❌ Some traders report stricter evaluation rules
When to Choose
Ultimately, the right prop firm depends on your trading style and priorities. Here are some scenarios that can help you decide.
If you want to trade multiple asset classes beyond Forex, such as Futures and Stocks, and if regulatory safety is a priority, TTP is a strong option. It suits traders who think long-term and value compliance, even if profit splits are slightly lower.
If you’re looking for higher immediate payouts, fast withdrawal options, and a strong support community, Blue Guardian might be better. It’s particularly appealing if you prefer simple 1-Step or 2-Step challenges and appreciate the chance to get your evaluation fees refunded.
Side-by-Side Summary
A direct comparison of the most important factors.
| Factor | The Trading Pit | Blue Guardian |
|---|---|---|
| Contract Transparency | Clear EU framework | Good, with restrictions |
| Profit Split | 50–80% | Up to 90% |
| Payout Speed | ≈14 days | Instant–1 week |
| Fee Refund | No highlight | After payout milestones |
| Legal Reliability | High (EU standards) | Moderate, internal policies |
| Community & Brand | Moderate presence | Strong Discord + football sponsorship |
Sources
This comparison is fact-checked against multiple reliable sources:
- The Trading Pit Official Website
- Blue Guardian Official Website
- WRTrading Review
- TheTrustedProp Review
- Trader community feedback on Trustpilot & Discord
Conclusion
Both The Trading Pit and Blue Guardian offer value, but in different ways. TTP is built on compliance and transparency, with broader asset access and regulated broker connections — perfect for traders seeking long-term stability. BG focuses on profit maximization, speed, and community, ideal for traders who want fast results and higher take-home earnings.
There is no universal “best” prop firm. The right choice depends on whether you prioritize safety and transparency (The Trading Pit) or maximum profit and fast access to payouts (Blue Guardian). A practical approach may even be to test both with smaller accounts before committing larger capital.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes. The Trading Pit is headquartered in Liechtenstein under a European legal framework and partners with regulated brokers such as FXFlat and WH SelfInvest to ensure transparent execution and compliance.
Yes. Blue Guardian offers up to 90% profit split on eligible programs. In practice, many traders report average splits around 85%, which is still among the highest in the industry.
The Trading Pit supports MT4, MT5, cTrader, DXtrade, and NinjaTrader, giving traders a wide choice of industry-standard platforms.
Blue Guardian offers 1-Step, 2-Step, 3-Step, and Instant Funding programs, designed to suit different trading styles and risk tolerances.
The Trading Pit typically processes payouts every 14 days, subject to requirements such as minimum profitable days, providing structured and predictable withdrawals.
Blue Guardian is known for quick payouts. Most traders receive funds within a week, and crypto withdrawals (BTC, ETH, USDT, etc.) can be nearly instant.
No. Evaluation fee refunds are not a core feature of The Trading Pit. Instead, the firm emphasizes clear contracts, regulatory compliance, and long-term trader security.
Yes. Blue Guardian refunds evaluation fees once traders reach payout milestones, effectively reducing the long-term cost of trading with the firm.
Blue Guardian restricts traders from numerous countries (list changes over time). See the official Restricted Countries section in their FAQ for the current list.
It depends on your goals. The Trading Pit is ideal if you value EU compliance, multi-asset coverage, and transparent regulatory standards. Blue Guardian is better if you prefer higher profit splits, faster withdrawals, fee refunds, and strong community support.